Register

Sign In

Login with facebook

FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

useravatar
SLE Photography
Offline
Photographer
Arnold, Maryland
Site Host
2547 Posts

Top FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

I just caught 2 articles, http://lens.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/0 … roparazzi/ & http://blogs.nppa.org/advocacy/2011/03/ … imes-fast/ about a newly elected Florida state senator (Republican from Hillsborough county) who's trying to pass a law that would make it a FELONY for anyone to photograph a farm or agricultural property, even if the shooter is standing on public property while doing it.

The bill is REALLY badly written, besides the obvious idiocy it doesn't clearly define a "farm" and in fact is loose enough that a house with a garden could be counted.  The guy has said (according to the NPAA) that he's planning to amend it to take away the felony charge if the person taking the photos isn't trespassing while doing the shooting, but that still leaves the bill as an overall mess.

What, you might ask, is the NEED for this bill since trespassing (what the first part of the bill covers) is already illegal?  He's trying to stamp out the creeping socialism of animal rights activists who might go on a property to document animal abuse.  No, seriously.  Some also suspect (noted in several comments from the NYT link) that he might be trying to stop documentation of abuse of migrant workers, since his district has a huge number of vegetable farms staffed largely by migrants.

As I said, this douchebag's a state senator, this isn't a national bill.  Full text of the bill is HERE .  I looked at his profile http://www.flsenate.gov/Senators/s12 and he introduced a FLURRY of fun bills yesterday, including an Arizona-style measure allowing cops to hassle anyone who looks foreign, a waiver to allow people to take guns in to elementary schools, a tax break for purchasing guns, and some bizarre resolution calling for the US constitution to be amended to protect foreign governments from being able to tell US parents how to raise their children.  No, I'm not making that up.

Apparently amongst all the other "evils" this guy sees that we need to be protected from, my photos of BARNS are high up on the list.  Hopefully the attention given to this idiocy will help make sure it doesn't pass.

I am a Model Insider site admin, please feel free to PM me with any site related issues, or for faster response contact our team via the Helpdesk

James Glendinning / SilverLight Esoterica Photography / SLE Photography

useravatar
Emeritus
Online
Photographer
Las Vegas, Nevada
Lounge Host
1174 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

As used in this section, the term “farm” includes any tract of land cultivated for the purpose of agricultural production, the raising and breeding of domestic animals, or the storage of a commodity.

Interesting.

I happen to have five pounds of flour stored in my pantry.  I guess I own a farm.

useravatar
Emeritus
Online
Photographer
Las Vegas, Nevada
Lounge Host
1174 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Photograph of a Florida farm.   Actually, of a lot of Florida farms.  Is this one count of felony photographing, or many?  I wonder if the folks at Terrametrics are going to jail?

useravatar
SLE Photography
Offline
Photographer
Arnold, Maryland
Site Host
2547 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Roger, you point out 2 of the major holes in this bill.  As it's written a farm is almost ANYTHING, and the people at Google cleasrly have to spend the rest of their lives in jail for Google Earth and Street View.

I am a Model Insider site admin, please feel free to PM me with any site related issues, or for faster response contact our team via the Helpdesk

James Glendinning / SilverLight Esoterica Photography / SLE Photography

useravatar
Aruna Advaney
Offline
Female Model
Naperville, Illinois
56 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Can anyone say the thread title ten times fast?  smile

useravatar
John Rayner
Offline
Photographer
Rapid City, South Dakota
1325 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Sounds like this guys idol is Joe Mcarthy.

useravatar
Greg Cobb
Offline
Photographer
Southaven, Mississippi
109 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

This is a reply I received from someone in the Army who is stationed overseas:

As major farms in our country supply lots of our food, they naturally are targets for terriost attacks. That may sound stupid, but a biological attack on our food supply is very possible and would be to easy. Taking pictures of land, buildings, and other "areas" is the easiest way to gather the information needed to develop plans.

-=gcobb=-

useravatar
SLE Photography
Offline
Photographer
Arnold, Maryland
Site Host
2547 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Greg Cobb wrote:

This is a reply I received from someone in the Army who is stationed overseas:

As major farms in our country supply lots of our food, they naturally are targets for terriost attacks. That may sound stupid, but a biological attack on our food supply is very possible and would be to easy. Taking pictures of land, buildings, and other "areas" is the easiest way to gather the information needed to develop plans.

Greg, I could actually understand that, to a point, although I still wouldn't agree with the idea of making it a felony to photograph any nebulously defined "agricultural area" from otherwise public land... among other things, it'd be too easy to break the law ACCIDENTALLY.

But more to the point this guy SAID it was because of "creeping socialism" in the form of animal rights activists, not a WORD about terrorists & the food supply.  Plus, as noted, his district & some of his biggest supporters have been burned by things like the ABC News hidden camera pieces on migrant worker abuse... and this would make that illegal.

I am a Model Insider site admin, please feel free to PM me with any site related issues, or for faster response contact our team via the Helpdesk

James Glendinning / SilverLight Esoterica Photography / SLE Photography

useravatar
Dare2 be Photography
Offline
Photographer
Wenatchee, Washington
239 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

I haven't read it but I guess that might also include  other "crops" including  weed grows 

this sounds really rediculous  and most likely violates some civil rights.  and definatly common sense.

useravatar
Dare2 be Photography
Offline
Photographer
Wenatchee, Washington
239 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Greg Cobb wrote:

This is a reply I received from someone in the Army who is stationed overseas:

As major farms in our country supply lots of our food, they naturally are targets for terriost attacks. That may sound stupid, but a biological attack on our food supply is very possible and would be to easy. Taking pictures of land, buildings, and other "areas" is the easiest way to gather the information needed to develop plans.

ugh  with that mind set  DIRT would be a stratigic material  that could also be vulnerable to attack   guess we better close the boarders and put up metal detectors  and make people get permits to use the "DIRT"   

crops out in the field would be a an exceedingly poor target  because of its sheer size and volume   it is magnatudes more effective to attack the food after its picked but even then you would have to do ALOT to have any large effect.

even if someone tried to infect crops with some form of blight banning photography would do nothing to effect that.

useravatar
Lumigraphics
Offline
Photographer
Lansing, Michigan
749 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

What do you expect? Its Florida.
And I'm sick of every idiotic idea being blamed on the "terrorists." All that is doing is letting them win. The day the terrorists lose is the day that not one person wastes a second thinking about them.
Finally- if I wanted to attack a civilian population, I'd go after three things- the power grid, the water supply, and the transportation network. Blow up a few bridges and power generation facilities and poison a reservoir or two and you'd shut down the normal lives of millions of people.

useravatar
Justin Photo
Offline
Photographer
Munich
96 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

http://www.salon.com/news/agriculture/i … y_open2011

Not sure about the interpretation given, "Norman is toting water for large agribusinesses" Salon is after all a supremely left leaning web site. Interesting never-the-less.

useravatar
Peter Flanagan
Offline
Photographer
Downers Grove, Illinois
238 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

I'm all for tax breaks on guns.

useravatar
Greg Cobb
Offline
Photographer
Southaven, Mississippi
109 Posts

Top Re: FELONY to photograph a farm in Florida??

Dare2 be Photography wrote:

Greg Cobb wrote:

This is a reply I received from someone in the Army who is stationed overseas:

As major farms in our country supply lots of our food, they naturally are targets for terriost attacks. That may sound stupid, but a biological attack on our food supply is very possible and would be to easy. Taking pictures of land, buildings, and other "areas" is the easiest way to gather the information needed to develop plans.

ugh  with that mind set  DIRT would be a stratigic material  that could also be vulnerable to attack   guess we better close the boarders and put up metal detectors  and make people get permits to use the "DIRT"   

crops out in the field would be a an exceedingly poor target  because of its sheer size and volume   it is magnatudes more effective to attack the food after its picked but even then you would have to do ALOT to have any large effect.

even if someone tried to infect crops with some form of blight banning photography would do nothing to effect that.

Look up over your head.  smile

-=gcobb=-